To learn the process I watched America's Test Kitchen Beef Wellington video, Chef Jon's video, Gordon Ramsay's video, a few shorts, Fallow's Beef Wellington Guide, and Chris Young's video, just to name a few. I will add my references at the end.
I took most of my inspiration from Chef Jon. He advised to keep realistic expectations. The meat is going to exude juices all over once you cut into the roast. The pastry is going to get a little soggy. Accept that. His tip is to bake extra pieces of puff pastry to serve with the Wellington, that way you still can have plenty of crispy, flaky pastry to go with the meat. He also prefers a more simplistic method and avoids the use of crepes or prosciutto.
I started by making the duxelles ahead of time. I knew that school would be back in session at the time of my birthday and it would be difficult to pull off the extra steps if I waited until the week that I needed the components.
I minced 2 ½ pounds of mushrooms by hand. I substituted onions for shallots and used a tiny bit of balsamic vinegar in place of wine. I seasoned the mushrooms with salt, pepper, bay leaf, and thyme. I didn't have any truffle infused pāté that Chef Jon recommended but I had some homemade liver pāté so I mixed in a spoonful of that once the mushrooms had finished cooking down.
Three days ahead I pulled the meat out of the freezer to thaw. I had two small pieces of deer back strap in one bag. I would make two small Wellingtons. I thought it would be the perfect amount for my family and I would be able to cook them effectively in my toaster oven.Next I spread the duxelles onto the pastry, and rolled the piece of meat up in the pastry like a fat sausage in a blanket. I brushed it with egg wash.I really wanted to add a lattice ornament to my pastry. I had no lattice cutter but when I was little my mom let us play with hers when we had playdough. I remembered how it cut the dough and I tried to replicate the pattern on a section of puff pastry using a ruler and knife.Voilà! I was so happy with these lattices! They were perfect! (Perfect enough for me.) Everything got another coat of egg wash.
I baked the Wellingtons at 450° F. for 27 minutes. The internal temperature reached 122° F. I removed them from the pan to a cutting board. After resting 5 minutes the temperature had risen to 150°F. The meat was perfectly cooked. It was between medium/rare and medium. What a relief. One of my main concerns was getting the meat cooked right without over cooking it. I opted not to sear the roast because I just knew I would over cook it, if I attempted a sear. American's Test Kitchen left out the searing in their recipe, too, so I was in good company.




























































